| By: Harrison | H.B. No. 3808 | |
|
A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
|
||
|
AN ACT
|
||
| relating to the creation of the artificial intelligence advisory | ||
| council and the establishment of the artificial intelligence | ||
| learning laboratory. | ||
| BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS: | ||
| SECTION 1. Chapter 2054, Government Code, is amended by | ||
| adding Subchapter S to read as follows: | ||
| SUBCHAPTER S. ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ADVISORY COUNCIL | ||
| Sec. 2054.621. DEFINITIONS. In this subchapter: | ||
| (1) "Algorithm" means a computerized procedure | ||
| consisting of a set of steps used to accomplish a determined task. | ||
| (2) "Artificial intelligence systems" means systems | ||
| capable of: | ||
| (A) perceiving an environment through data | ||
| acquisition and processing and interpreting the derived | ||
| information to take an action or actions or to imitate intelligent | ||
| behavior given a specific goal; and | ||
| (B) learning and adapting behavior by analyzing | ||
| how the environment is affected by prior actions. | ||
| (3) "Automated decision system" means an algorithm, | ||
| including an algorithm incorporating machine learning or other | ||
| artificial intelligence techniques, that uses data-based analytics | ||
| to make or support governmental decisions, judgments, or | ||
| conclusions. | ||
| (4) "Automated final decision system" means an | ||
| automated decision system that makes final decisions, judgments, or | ||
| conclusions without human intervention. | ||
| (5) "Automated support decision system" means an | ||
| automated decision system that provides information to inform the | ||
| final decision, judgment, or conclusion of a human decision maker. | ||
| (6) "Council" means the artificial intelligence | ||
| advisory council established under this subchapter. | ||
| Sec. 2054.622. ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ADVISORY COUNCIL. | ||
| (a) The council is composed of the following seven members: | ||
| (1) one member of the house of representatives | ||
| appointed by the speaker of the house of representatives; | ||
| (2) one member of the senate appointed by the | ||
| lieutenant governor; | ||
| (3) the executive director or the executive director's | ||
| designee; and | ||
| (4) the following four members appointed by the | ||
| governor: | ||
| (A) an expert on ethics; | ||
| (B) an expert on artificial intelligence | ||
| systems; | ||
| (C) an expert on law enforcement usage of | ||
| artificial intelligence systems; and | ||
| (D) an expert on constitutional and legal rights. | ||
| (b) The council members appointed under Subsections (a)(1) | ||
| and (2) shall serve as co-chairs of the council. | ||
| (c) A member of the council is not entitled to compensation | ||
| or reimbursement for expenses. | ||
| (d) The department shall provide administrative support for | ||
| the council. | ||
| (e) The council shall meet at the call of the co-chairs. The | ||
| council may meet in person or by telephone conference call, | ||
| videoconference, or another similar telecommunication method. | ||
| Notwithstanding Chapter 551 or any other law, a meeting held by | ||
| telephone conference call, videoconference, or another similar | ||
| telecommunication method is subject to the requirements of Sections | ||
| 551.125(c), (d), (e), and (f). | ||
| (f) The council shall study and monitor artificial | ||
| intelligence systems developed, employed, or procured by state | ||
| agencies. In carrying out its duties under this section, the | ||
| council shall: | ||
| (1) assess the need for a state code of ethics for | ||
| artificial intelligence systems in state government; | ||
| (2) review automated decision systems inventory | ||
| reports submitted by state agencies under Section 2054.623, | ||
| including a review of: | ||
| (A) the effect of the automated decision systems | ||
| on the constitutional or legal rights, duties, or privileges of the | ||
| residents of this state; and | ||
| (B) the potential benefits, liabilities, or | ||
| risks that this state could incur as a result of implementing the | ||
| automated decision systems; and | ||
| (3) recommend administrative actions that state | ||
| agencies may take without further legislative authorization. | ||
| (g) Not later than December 1, 2026, the council shall | ||
| submit a report to the governor and the legislature that includes: | ||
| (1) a summary of the council's findings after | ||
| reviewing: | ||
| (A) the automated decision systems inventory | ||
| reports submitted under Section 2054.623; and | ||
| (B) the results of the artificial intelligence | ||
| learning laboratory under Section 2054.624; | ||
| (2) a summary of the recommendations of any relevant | ||
| national bodies on artificial intelligence systems in state | ||
| government; | ||
| (3) an assessment of the impact of using artificial | ||
| intelligence systems in state government on the liberty, finances, | ||
| livelihood, and privacy interests of the residents of this state; | ||
| (4) recommendations of the least stringent policies | ||
| necessary to: | ||
| (A) protect the privacy and interests of the | ||
| residents of this state from any diminution caused by employment of | ||
| artificial intelligence systems by state government; | ||
| (B) ensure that the residents of this state are | ||
| free from unfair discrimination caused or compounded by the | ||
| employment of artificial intelligence systems in state government; | ||
| and | ||
| (C) promote workforce knowledge of artificial | ||
| intelligence technology and the development of ethical artificial | ||
| intelligence systems in state government; and | ||
| (5) any other information that the council considers | ||
| relevant. | ||
| (h) Section 2110.008 does not apply to the council. | ||
| Sec. 2054.623. AUTOMATED DECISION SYSTEMS INVENTORY | ||
| REPORT. (a) Not later than July 1, 2026, each agency in the | ||
| executive and legislative branches of state government, using money | ||
| appropriated to the agency by this state, shall submit an inventory | ||
| report of all automated decision systems that are being developed, | ||
| employed, or procured by the agency. For each automated decision | ||
| system, the inventory report must include a description of: | ||
| (1) the name and vendor of the automated decision | ||
| system, if any; | ||
| (2) the automated decision system's general | ||
| capabilities, including: | ||
| (A) reasonably foreseeable capabilities outside | ||
| the scope of the agency's proposed use; and | ||
| (B) whether the automated decision system is used | ||
| or may be used for independent decision-making powers and the | ||
| impact of those decisions on the residents of this state; | ||
| (3) the types of data inputs that the technology uses; | ||
| (4) how the data described by Subdivision (3) is | ||
| generated, collected, and processed; | ||
| (5) the types of data the automated decision system is | ||
| reasonably likely to generate; | ||
| (6) whether the automated decision system has been | ||
| tested by an independent third party, has a known bias, or is | ||
| untested for bias; | ||
| (7) the purpose and proposed use of the automated | ||
| decision system, including: | ||
| (A) the decisions the automated decision system | ||
| will be used to make or support; | ||
| (B) whether the automated decision system is an | ||
| automated final decision system or an automated support decision | ||
| system; and | ||
| (C) the automated decision system's intended | ||
| benefits, including any data or research relevant to the outcome of | ||
| those results; | ||
| (8) how automated decision system data is securely | ||
| stored and processed and whether the agency intends to share access | ||
| to the automated decision system or data from that automated | ||
| decision system with any other entity, and why; and | ||
| (9) the information technology fiscal impacts of the | ||
| automated decision system, including: | ||
| (A) initial acquisition costs and ongoing | ||
| operating costs, such as maintenance, licensing, personnel, legal | ||
| compliance, use auditing, data retention, and security costs; | ||
| (B) any cost savings that would be achieved | ||
| through the use of the technology; and | ||
| (C) any current or potential sources of funding, | ||
| including any subsidies or free products being offered by vendors | ||
| or governmental entities. | ||
| (b) Not later than March 1, 2026, the council, in | ||
| consultation with the department, shall prescribe the form, | ||
| contents, and manner of submission of the automated decision | ||
| systems inventory report required under this section. | ||
| (c) Each agency shall submit the report required under this | ||
| section to the: | ||
| (1) department; | ||
| (2) council; and | ||
| (3) standing committees of the senate and house of | ||
| representatives with primary jurisdiction over state agency | ||
| information technology. | ||
| Sec. 2054.624. ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE LEARNING | ||
| LABORATORY. (a) In this section: | ||
| (1) "Learning laboratory" means the artificial | ||
| intelligence learning laboratory established under this section. | ||
| (2) "Participant" means an entity selected by the | ||
| council to participate in the artificial intelligence learning | ||
| laboratory established under this section, including a state | ||
| agency, a business entity, a nonprofit organization, or an open | ||
| source project. | ||
| (3) "Regulatory mitigation agreement" means an | ||
| agreement between the council and a participant for the purpose of | ||
| permitting the participant to use and test artificial intelligence | ||
| systems with limited legal and regulatory boundaries. | ||
| (4) "State agency" means, notwithstanding Section | ||
| 2054.003, an agency in the legislative or executive branch of state | ||
| government. | ||
| (b) The council shall, with assistance from the department, | ||
| establish the artificial intelligence learning laboratory. The | ||
| council shall operate the learning laboratory to: | ||
| (1) evaluate the benefits, risks, and impact of | ||
| regulations on artificial intelligence; | ||
| (2) encourage the development of artificial | ||
| intelligence in state agencies; and | ||
| (3) produce recommendations for the least stringent | ||
| legislation on or regulation of artificial intelligence. | ||
| (c) The council shall set, and update as necessary, a | ||
| learning agenda for the learning laboratory to establish specific | ||
| areas of artificial intelligence policy to study. The learning | ||
| agenda must outline the parameters for the type of artificial | ||
| intelligence systems to be tested by a participant. In setting the | ||
| learning agenda, the council may consult state agencies, industry | ||
| leaders, and other key stakeholders the council considers | ||
| appropriate. | ||
| (d) The council shall establish an application process and | ||
| criteria to select participants for the learning laboratory. The | ||
| council shall, in selecting participants, consider: | ||
| (1) the relevance and utility of the applicant's | ||
| artificial intelligence technology to the learning agenda; | ||
| (2) the applicant's expertise and knowledge specific | ||
| to the learning agenda; | ||
| (3) the applicant's plan to monitor and minimize use | ||
| when testing the artificial intelligence systems; | ||
| (4) whether the applicant is eligible for regulatory | ||
| mitigation as described by Section 2054.626; and | ||
| (5) any other factor the council determines relevant. | ||
| (e) In collaboration with each participant, the council | ||
| shall establish benchmarks and assess outcomes of participation in | ||
| the learning laboratory. | ||
| (f) An applicant approved for participation must enter into | ||
| a regulatory mitigation agreement under Section 2054.625. | ||
| (g) A participant of the learning laboratory shall conduct | ||
| experiments using artificial intelligence systems, automated | ||
| decision systems, automated final decision systems, or automated | ||
| support decision systems that fall within the scope of the learning | ||
| agenda. | ||
| (h) A participant shall retain all records and provide | ||
| requested information and findings to the council. A participant | ||
| shall submit a report to the council, including: | ||
| (1) a summary of the proposed artificial intelligence | ||
| systems; | ||
| (2) the results from operating the artificial | ||
| intelligence systems; and | ||
| (3) any other information the council determines as | ||
| necessary and relevant. | ||
| (i) The council shall submit to the legislature, the | ||
| standing committees of each house with jurisdiction over artificial | ||
| intelligence systems, and the governor a report containing the | ||
| results of the learning laboratory findings and suggestions of the | ||
| least stringent legal and regulatory policies in relation to the | ||
| artificial intelligence systems studied by the learning | ||
| laboratory. | ||
| (j) The department may adopt rules to implement this | ||
| section. | ||
| Sec. 2054.625. REGULATORY MITIGATION AGREEMENTS. (a) A | ||
| participant in the learning laboratory shall enter into an | ||
| agreement as provided by this section. | ||
| (b) The agreement must provide: | ||
| (1) limitations on the artificial intelligence | ||
| systems to be tested, including: | ||
| (A) the number and types of users; | ||
| (B) geographic limitations; and | ||
| (C) any other limitation the department | ||
| considers advisable; | ||
| (2) procedures to protect the health and safety of | ||
| this state during the testing period; | ||
| (3) that the participant does not have any expectation | ||
| of a property right or license to participate in the learning | ||
| laboratory; | ||
| (4) that committing certain violations of law or a | ||
| violation of the agreement, as determined by the department, is | ||
| grounds for removal from the learning laboratory; | ||
| (5) that participation in the learning laboratory does | ||
| not constitute an endorsement by the state and is not a factor in | ||
| any criminal or civil proceeding; | ||
| (6) that the state is not responsible for any claims, | ||
| liabilities, damages, losses, or expenses arising out of the | ||
| participant's involvement in the learning laboratory; and | ||
| (7) that the participant will: | ||
| (A) provide information to the department and any | ||
| other state agency the department considers necessary to | ||
| successfully test artificial intelligence systems under the | ||
| learning laboratory program; and | ||
| (B) report to the department under the terms | ||
| acceptable to the department. | ||
| (c) An agreement under this section may be entered into by a | ||
| participant, the department, and other state agencies the | ||
| department considers necessary for regulatory mitigation as | ||
| described by Subsection (d). The department shall consult with | ||
| other state agencies on appropriate terms of regulatory mitigation | ||
| to provide under Subsection (d). | ||
| (d) An agreement under this section may provide for the | ||
| following regulatory mitigation measures: | ||
| (1) circumstances under which a participant: | ||
| (A) is or is not required to provide restitution | ||
| to a user of the artificial intelligence system under testing; | ||
| (B) may have an opportunity to correct any | ||
| violations of law that occur from using the system described by this | ||
| section before penalties are imposed by the state; and | ||
| (C) may be entitled to reduced civil penalties | ||
| during the period in which the agreement is in effect; and | ||
| (2) any other measures to address risks that the | ||
| department considers advisable. | ||
| (e) An agreement under this section has a term of one year | ||
| and may be extended on request by the participant for an additional | ||
| year, if the request is submitted not later than 30 days before the | ||
| date that the agreement's term ends. The department shall approve | ||
| or deny the request before the date that the agreement's term ends. | ||
| Sec. 2054.626. ELIGIBILITY. An applicant for participation | ||
| in the learning laboratory is eligible for regulatory mitigation as | ||
| described by Section 2054.625 if: | ||
| (1) the applicant has the technical expertise and | ||
| capability to responsibly deploy and test the proposed artificial | ||
| intelligence systems; | ||
| (2) the applicant has sufficient financial resources | ||
| to meet obligations during the testing period; | ||
| (3) the proposed artificial intelligence systems | ||
| provide substantial consumer benefits that may outweigh identified | ||
| risks from permitting regulatory mitigation; | ||
| (4) the applicant has an effective plan to monitor and | ||
| minimize identified risks from testing; and | ||
| (5) the scale, scope, and duration of proposed testing | ||
| is appropriately limited based on risk assessments. | ||
| Sec. 2054.627. COUNCIL ABOLISHED; EXPIRATION OF | ||
| SUBCHAPTER. The council is abolished and this subchapter expires | ||
| September 1, 2029. | ||
| SECTION 2. (a) As soon as practicable after the effective | ||
| date of this Act but not later than October 1, 2025, the appropriate | ||
| appointing authorities shall appoint the members to the artificial | ||
| intelligence advisory council as required by Section 2054.622, | ||
| Government Code, as added by this Act. | ||
| (b) Not later than November 1, 2025, the advisory council | ||
| established under Subchapter S, Chapter 2054, Government Code, as | ||
| added by this Act, shall hold its initial meeting. | ||
| (c) Not later than December 1, 2025, the advisory council | ||
| established under Subchapter S, Chapter 2054, Government Code, as | ||
| added by this Act, shall establish the artificial intelligence | ||
| learning laboratory as required by Section 2054.624, Government | ||
| Code, as added by this Act. | ||
| SECTION 3. This Act takes effect immediately if it receives | ||
| a vote of two-thirds of all the members elected to each house, as | ||
| provided by Section 39, Article III, Texas Constitution. If this | ||
| Act does not receive the vote necessary for immediate effect, this | ||
| Act takes effect September 1, 2025. | ||